full transcript

From the Ted Talk by Alex Gendler: Myths and misconceptions about evolution

Unscramble the Blue Letters

Myths and misconceptions about evolution. Let's talk about evolution. You've probably heard that some people consider it controversial, even though most scientists don't. But even if you aren't one of those people and you think you have a pretty good understanding of evolution, chances are you still believe some things about it that aren't entirely right, things like, "Evolution is organisms adapting to their environment." This was an earlier, now discredited, theory of evolution. Almost 60 years before diawrn phbiuseld his book, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck proposed that creatures evolve by developing certain ttaris over their lifetimes and then pissang those on to their offspring. For example, he thought that because giraffes spent their lveis stretching to reach leaves on hgheir branches, their children would be born with longer nkces. But we know now that's not how gtneeic inheritance works. In fact, individual organisms don't eovvle at all. Instead, random genetic moittunas cause some giraffes to be born with longer necks, and that gives them a better chance to survive than the ones who weren't so lucky, which brings us to "survival of the fittest". This makes it sound like evolution always favors the bgesgit, strongest, or fastest creatures, which is not really the case. For one thing, evolutionary fnitses is just a matter of how well-suited they are to their curnert environment. If all the tall trees suddenly died out and only short grass was left, all those long-necked giraffes would be at a disadvantage. Secondly, survival is not how euootivln occurs, rrpoioedctun is. And the world if full of creatures like the male anglerfish, which is so small and ill-suited for suvvrial at birth that it has to quickly find a mate before it dies. But at least we can say that if an organism dies without reproducing, it's evolutionarily useless, right? Wrong! Remember, natural selection happens not at the organism lveel, but at the genetic level, and the same gene that exists in one organism will also esxit in its retiaelvs. So, a gene that makes an animal atriclsltaliuy sacrifice itself to help the survival and future reproduction of its siblings or cousins, can become more weapiesrdd than one that is seloly concerned with self-preservation. Anything that lets more copies of the gene pass on to the next generation will serve its purpose, except evolutionary purpose. One of the most difficult things to keep in mind about evolution is that when we say things like, "Genes want to make more copies of themselves," or even, "natural selection," we're actually using metaphors. A gene doesn't want anything, and there's no outside mhnacsiem that stceels which genes are best to preserve. All that happens is that random genetic mutations cause the organisms carrying them to behave or dolveep in different ways. Some of those ways result in more copies of the mutated gene being passed on, and so forth. Nor is there any predetermined plan progressing towards an ideal form. It's not ideal for the human eye to have a blind spot where the optic nerve exits the rntiea, but that's how it developed, starting from a simple pceoetrpotohr cell. In retrospect, it would have been much more advantageous for humans to crave nutrients and vitamins rather than just calories. But over the mienllia,

Open Cloze

Myths and misconceptions about evolution. Let's talk about evolution. You've probably heard that some people consider it controversial, even though most scientists don't. But even if you aren't one of those people and you think you have a pretty good understanding of evolution, chances are you still believe some things about it that aren't entirely right, things like, "Evolution is organisms adapting to their environment." This was an earlier, now discredited, theory of evolution. Almost 60 years before ______ _________ his book, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck proposed that creatures evolve by developing certain ______ over their lifetimes and then _______ those on to their offspring. For example, he thought that because giraffes spent their _____ stretching to reach leaves on ______ branches, their children would be born with longer _____. But we know now that's not how _______ inheritance works. In fact, individual organisms don't ______ at all. Instead, random genetic _________ cause some giraffes to be born with longer necks, and that gives them a better chance to survive than the ones who weren't so lucky, which brings us to "survival of the fittest". This makes it sound like evolution always favors the _______, strongest, or fastest creatures, which is not really the case. For one thing, evolutionary _______ is just a matter of how well-suited they are to their _______ environment. If all the tall trees suddenly died out and only short grass was left, all those long-necked giraffes would be at a disadvantage. Secondly, survival is not how _________ occurs, ____________ is. And the world if full of creatures like the male anglerfish, which is so small and ill-suited for ________ at birth that it has to quickly find a mate before it dies. But at least we can say that if an organism dies without reproducing, it's evolutionarily useless, right? Wrong! Remember, natural selection happens not at the organism _____, but at the genetic level, and the same gene that exists in one organism will also _____ in its _________. So, a gene that makes an animal ______________ sacrifice itself to help the survival and future reproduction of its siblings or cousins, can become more __________ than one that is ______ concerned with self-preservation. Anything that lets more copies of the gene pass on to the next generation will serve its purpose, except evolutionary purpose. One of the most difficult things to keep in mind about evolution is that when we say things like, "Genes want to make more copies of themselves," or even, "natural selection," we're actually using metaphors. A gene doesn't want anything, and there's no outside _________ that _______ which genes are best to preserve. All that happens is that random genetic mutations cause the organisms carrying them to behave or _______ in different ways. Some of those ways result in more copies of the mutated gene being passed on, and so forth. Nor is there any predetermined plan progressing towards an ideal form. It's not ideal for the human eye to have a blind spot where the optic nerve exits the ______, but that's how it developed, starting from a simple _____________ cell. In retrospect, it would have been much more advantageous for humans to crave nutrients and vitamins rather than just calories. But over the ________,

Solution

  1. relatives
  2. widespread
  3. altruistically
  4. photoreceptor
  5. solely
  6. fitness
  7. higher
  8. evolve
  9. traits
  10. lives
  11. mutations
  12. evolution
  13. level
  14. current
  15. darwin
  16. retina
  17. survival
  18. biggest
  19. published
  20. millenia
  21. mechanism
  22. exist
  23. genetic
  24. necks
  25. reproduction
  26. passing
  27. selects
  28. develop

Original Text

Myths and misconceptions about evolution. Let's talk about evolution. You've probably heard that some people consider it controversial, even though most scientists don't. But even if you aren't one of those people and you think you have a pretty good understanding of evolution, chances are you still believe some things about it that aren't entirely right, things like, "Evolution is organisms adapting to their environment." This was an earlier, now discredited, theory of evolution. Almost 60 years before Darwin published his book, Jean-Baptiste Lamarck proposed that creatures evolve by developing certain traits over their lifetimes and then passing those on to their offspring. For example, he thought that because giraffes spent their lives stretching to reach leaves on higher branches, their children would be born with longer necks. But we know now that's not how genetic inheritance works. In fact, individual organisms don't evolve at all. Instead, random genetic mutations cause some giraffes to be born with longer necks, and that gives them a better chance to survive than the ones who weren't so lucky, which brings us to "survival of the fittest". This makes it sound like evolution always favors the biggest, strongest, or fastest creatures, which is not really the case. For one thing, evolutionary fitness is just a matter of how well-suited they are to their current environment. If all the tall trees suddenly died out and only short grass was left, all those long-necked giraffes would be at a disadvantage. Secondly, survival is not how evolution occurs, reproduction is. And the world if full of creatures like the male anglerfish, which is so small and ill-suited for survival at birth that it has to quickly find a mate before it dies. But at least we can say that if an organism dies without reproducing, it's evolutionarily useless, right? Wrong! Remember, natural selection happens not at the organism level, but at the genetic level, and the same gene that exists in one organism will also exist in its relatives. So, a gene that makes an animal altruistically sacrifice itself to help the survival and future reproduction of its siblings or cousins, can become more widespread than one that is solely concerned with self-preservation. Anything that lets more copies of the gene pass on to the next generation will serve its purpose, except evolutionary purpose. One of the most difficult things to keep in mind about evolution is that when we say things like, "Genes want to make more copies of themselves," or even, "natural selection," we're actually using metaphors. A gene doesn't want anything, and there's no outside mechanism that selects which genes are best to preserve. All that happens is that random genetic mutations cause the organisms carrying them to behave or develop in different ways. Some of those ways result in more copies of the mutated gene being passed on, and so forth. Nor is there any predetermined plan progressing towards an ideal form. It's not ideal for the human eye to have a blind spot where the optic nerve exits the retina, but that's how it developed, starting from a simple photoreceptor cell. In retrospect, it would have been much more advantageous for humans to crave nutrients and vitamins rather than just calories. But over the millenia,

Frequently Occurring Word Combinations

ngrams of length 2

collocation frequency
random genetic 2
genetic mutations 2

ngrams of length 3

collocation frequency
random genetic mutations 2

Important Words

  1. adapting
  2. advantageous
  3. altruistically
  4. anglerfish
  5. animal
  6. behave
  7. biggest
  8. birth
  9. blind
  10. book
  11. born
  12. branches
  13. brings
  14. calories
  15. carrying
  16. case
  17. cell
  18. chance
  19. chances
  20. children
  21. concerned
  22. controversial
  23. copies
  24. cousins
  25. crave
  26. creatures
  27. current
  28. darwin
  29. develop
  30. developed
  31. developing
  32. died
  33. dies
  34. difficult
  35. disadvantage
  36. discredited
  37. earlier
  38. environment
  39. evolution
  40. evolutionarily
  41. evolutionary
  42. evolve
  43. exist
  44. exists
  45. exits
  46. eye
  47. fact
  48. fastest
  49. favors
  50. find
  51. fitness
  52. form
  53. full
  54. future
  55. gene
  56. generation
  57. genes
  58. genetic
  59. giraffes
  60. good
  61. grass
  62. heard
  63. higher
  64. human
  65. humans
  66. ideal
  67. individual
  68. inheritance
  69. lamarck
  70. leaves
  71. left
  72. lets
  73. level
  74. lifetimes
  75. lives
  76. longer
  77. lucky
  78. male
  79. mate
  80. matter
  81. mechanism
  82. metaphors
  83. millenia
  84. mind
  85. misconceptions
  86. mutated
  87. mutations
  88. myths
  89. natural
  90. necks
  91. nerve
  92. nutrients
  93. occurs
  94. offspring
  95. optic
  96. organism
  97. organisms
  98. pass
  99. passed
  100. passing
  101. people
  102. photoreceptor
  103. plan
  104. predetermined
  105. preserve
  106. pretty
  107. progressing
  108. proposed
  109. published
  110. purpose
  111. quickly
  112. random
  113. reach
  114. relatives
  115. remember
  116. reproducing
  117. reproduction
  118. result
  119. retina
  120. retrospect
  121. sacrifice
  122. scientists
  123. selection
  124. selects
  125. serve
  126. short
  127. siblings
  128. simple
  129. small
  130. solely
  131. sound
  132. spent
  133. spot
  134. starting
  135. stretching
  136. strongest
  137. suddenly
  138. survival
  139. survive
  140. talk
  141. tall
  142. theory
  143. thought
  144. traits
  145. trees
  146. understanding
  147. useless
  148. vitamins
  149. ways
  150. widespread
  151. works
  152. world
  153. years